SHOCKING FOX NEWS REVEAL: Gutfeld, Perino, and Pirro Go into OVERDRIVE Behind the Cameras to Get Ready for Kat Timpf’s Live Return—But Whispers of “Unfinished Business” Have Viewers Asking: What’s About to Explode on May 12?

Three FOX News Stars—Greg Gutfeld, Dana Perino, and Judge Jeanine Pirro—Work Day and Night to Prepare for Kat Timpf’s Dramatic Return on May 12!

After weeks of silence, speculation, and subtle hints, The Five is bracing for what insiders are calling “the most anticipated comeback of the year.” Kat Timpf—brilliant, sarcastic, and recently missing from the lineup—is set to return live on May 12… and her co-hosts are pulling out all the stops.

But this isn’t just a welcome-back party. It’s a behind-the-scenes scramble, a tension-laced effort to get everything perfect for a return that’s been shrouded in mystery and emotional weight.

And now we know why.

THE PREPARATION IS INTENSE—AND SECRETIVE

Sources close to production confirm that Greg Gutfeld, Dana Perino, and Judge Jeanine Pirro have been staying late after tapings, reviewing scripts, coordinating segment shifts, and even adjusting on-air chemistry plans.

“Greg’s rewriting his jokes,” a floor producer revealed. “Dana’s rehearsing possible talking points. Jeanine’s even reviewing body language dynamics. They want it flawless—but more importantly—they want to be ready.”

Ready for what?

That’s the million-dollar question.

KAT’S ABSENCE—AND THE UNANSWERED QUESTIONS

Kat Timpf hasn’t appeared on The Five since her emotional exit weeks ago, just before giving birth and revealing her shocking cancer diagnosis during pregnancy—a revelation that shook both the studio and her audience.

While she’s stayed relatively quiet, posting only a few cryptic updates online, one message hit viewers hard:

“I’ll be back. Not just physically—mentally, emotionally, and stronger than ever. May 12.”

Fox immediately went into damage control and reputation prep mode.

BEHIND CLOSED DOORS: TENSIONS, TEARS, AND UNFINISHED BUSINESS

Multiple insiders confirm that there’s “unfinished business” between Kat and some of her co-hosts—most notably Greg Gutfeld.

Viewers will remember their last heated exchange before her disappearance, where a sarcastic joke about “pregnancy hormones” visibly rattled Timpf live on-air. While Gutfeld later offered an off-camera apology, the awkward tension never fully resolved.

“Greg’s anxious,” one insider admitted. “He’s trying to be funny without crossing the line this time. He knows all eyes will be on him.”

And he’s not the only one.

Judge Jeanine, normally fierce and unfiltered, has reportedly taken a softer tone in recent rehearsals—even asking producers to limit overlap between her monologues and Kat’s return commentary.

PRODUCERS ON EDGE

Showrunners are under pressure to balance emotional vulnerability with high energy. One misstep, one offhand comment, and it could erupt into a PR nightmare.

“Everyone wants this to be a moment of strength, redemption, and celebration,” said one senior producer. “But there’s tension. Real tension. Because Kat isn’t coming back quietly—she’s coming back transformed.”

WHAT FANS ARE SAYING

Fox News loyalists are buzzing across social media:

“Counting down to May 12—Kat Timpf is coming back and I KNOW it’s going to be powerful.”
— @TimpfNation

“Will Greg finally say what he should’ve said the night she walked off?”
— @NewsDramaDaily

“Kat’s return could change the entire dynamic of The Five. Don’t sleep on this.”
— @FoxInsiderFan

IS THIS JUST A RETURN—OR A RESET?

Analysts are already calling this moment “a pivot point” for The Five. With Kat Timpf’s return, viewers are expecting more than just banter—they’re expecting resolution, vulnerability, and maybe even confrontation.

Some speculate Kat may speak directly to her diagnosis, share untold details, or even address the emotional strain of being silenced on air at a critical point in her life.

Others believe a segment titled “Back, But Never the Same” is already in the works.

WHAT HAPPENS ON MAY 12?

No one knows exactly how it will play out—but one thing is certain:

The spotlight will be on Kat. The pressure will be on Gutfeld. And the fans? They’ll be watching every second.

With producers pacing backstage, co-hosts adjusting their delivery, and whispers of an unexpected “welcome-back twist” being scripted in secret, May 12 is shaping up to be not just television—but history.

And in a world where news moves fast, only one thing is guaranteed: