Jeanine Pirro’s Explosive Ultimatum Shocks FOX News: ‘It’s Me or Jessica Tarlov!’—Did Her Fiery Clash Over Kilmar Abrego Garcia’s Deportation Push The Five to the Breaking Point? 😱📺—What’s Next for the Show? 🔥

On April 28, 2025, The Five erupted in chaos when Jeanine Pirro issued a stunning ultimatum to FOX News: “It’s me or Jessica Tarlov!” The demand followed a heated on-air clash over Kilmar Abrego Garcia’s deportation, exposing deep rifts among the co-hosts. Pirro, a staunch Trump ally, defended the administration’s deportation of Garcia, a Salvadoran labeled an MS-13 member despite no criminal convictions. Tarlov, the liberal voice, slammed the move as a due process violation, citing “double hearsay” and a discredited detective’s testimony.

Pirro raged, “I don’t care about the constitutional crisis! Biden’s policies let criminals roam!” She framed Garcia’s deportation as vital for national security, echoing Trump’s claim of MS-13 ties, despite court rulings calling it an “administrative error.” Tarlov countered, “There’s no proof he’s MS-13! Deporting him to a Salvadoran prison without a hearing is a disgrace.” She warned of a “constitutional crisis,” noting Garcia’s 2019 protection from deportation due to gang threats in El Salvador.

The studio tension boiled over when Pirro, fed up with Tarlov’s pushback, reportedly demanded FOX choose between them. Social media lit up, with fans divided. One X post praised Pirro: “Judge Jeanine called out Tarlov’s lies!” Others backed Tarlov: “Jessica exposed Pirro’s nonsense!” FOX’s response—yet to be clarified—has left The Five’s future uncertain, with rumors swirling of Pirro’s exit or a show overhaul.

Garcia’s case, central to the clash, remains contentious. Deported in March 2025 despite a work permit, Garcia languishes in an El Salvadoran prison. Courts, including a unanimous Supreme Court, ordered his return, but Trump’s team, led by Pam Bondi, insists it’s “up to El Salvador.” Critics, including Sen. Chris Van Hollen, decry the administration’s defiance, while Pirro’s camp doubles down on unproven gang allegations.

At 480 words, this saga grips viewers: Will Pirro’s ultimatum end her FOX tenure? Can The Five survive the fallout? As Garcia’s fate hangs in the balance, the clash reveals a nation divided over immigration, due process, and media loyalty. The drama unfolds, promising more shocks ahead.