FOX WAR IGNITES: Jeanine Pirro’s SHOCKING Ultimatum to Fire Jessica Tarlov After Live Showdown Leaves Studio in SILENCE—Was This the Breaking Point or Just the Beginning of a Full-Blown Network Civil War?

It was the moment FOX News hoped no one would notice—but now, it’s all anyone can talk about.

Jeanine Pirro, known for her fiery takes and no-nonsense approach, reportedly exploded behind the scenes after a heated on-air exchange with liberal co-host Jessica Tarlov during a recent episode of The Five. According to multiple insiders, the clash wasn’t just another ideological squabble—it was personal, raw, and left the control room scrambling to contain the fallout. And now, Pirro wants Tarlov gone.

“It’s Her or Me,” Pirro Reportedly Said After the Show

While FOX News has yet to issue an official statement, sources within the network say Pirro immediately marched off set following the segment and confronted producers with an ultimatum: remove Tarlov permanently, or risk a full-blown internal revolt.

The incident occurred during a particularly charged segment about immigration policy, when Pirro accused Tarlov of “gaslighting the American people” and “defending lawlessness.” Tarlov, known for keeping her cool even under pressure, fired back—calling Pirro’s statements “reckless fear-mongering.”

What followed was nearly 45 seconds of unscripted crossfire that producers reportedly attempted to cut short with a commercial break. But the tension didn’t ease when cameras stopped rolling. According to a show staffer, “Jeanine was furious. She said Jessica was disrespectful and making the show unwatchable. She said, ‘She’s dragging the brand through the mud.’”

Backstage Fallout: “The Energy Was Radioactive”

The atmosphere backstage after the segment was described by one insider as “radioactive.” Co-hosts Greg Gutfeld and Jesse Watters reportedly tried to diffuse the situation, but neither was willing to take sides. “No one wants to be on the wrong end of Pirro’s fury—but at the same time, Jessica has quietly built a lot of goodwill at the network,” said the insider.

Tarlov, for her part, has remained professional, declining to comment publicly on the incident. But those close to her say she was “visibly shaken” and is now considering taking time off from the show. “She’s trying to hold her ground, but this was different. This crossed a line.”

Is This the Beginning of the End for The Five?

Fans of The Five are used to spirited debate, but this episode may have crossed a boundary the network can’t easily walk back from. Viewers lit up social media with reactions ranging from support for Pirro to outrage over her perceived bullying. Hashtags like #TeamTarlov and #FirePirro trended within hours of the segment airing.

Behind the scenes, the power struggle is just beginning. Executives are now said to be weighing their options carefully, knowing that either move—firing Tarlov or demoting Pirro—could alienate a core faction of their audience.

“Everyone’s walking on eggshells,” said one producer. “This isn’t just about ratings anymore. It’s about identity. Who does FOX News want to be?”

Why This Moment Feels Different

Pirro has had confrontations before. She’s even been temporarily suspended in the past. But this moment feels different because of who her target is: Jessica Tarlov is one of the few progressive voices on the network and represents a counterbalance that FOX often points to as proof of ideological diversity.

Removing her would send a message—and not everyone is comfortable with what that message would be.

At the same time, Pirro’s influence with conservative viewers remains unmatched. Her loyal base sees her as a truth-teller unafraid to challenge the status quo, and many are already voicing support for her demand.

As the network grapples with what to do next, one thing is clear: the public clash between Pirro and Tarlov has cracked open long-simmering tensions that can no longer be ignored.

And Now, All Eyes Are on FOX

Will FOX News bow to Pirro’s pressure and risk alienating moderate viewers? Or will they protect Tarlov and face the wrath of their most vocal host? The answer may reshape the network’s identity—and future—for years to come.

Whatever decision they make, this isn’t just a programming issue anymore. It’s a full-blown crisis.

Stay tuned, because this story is far from over.